An Argument in Defense of Haredi Jews and Against Secular Zionist Militarism

An Argument in Defense of Haredi Jews and Against Secular Zionist Militarism


It is one of the great ironies of history that the world’s modern secular anti-imperialist movements should find their most consequential allies among Israel’s most traditional and deeply religious movement.


by James Petras

Israel is heading towards a profound internal crisis: a Jew-on-Jew confrontation, which has major implications for its relations with the Palestinians, as well as its Arab neighbors. The conflict is between the highly militarized Zionist state and the Haredi religious movement over a number of issues, including recent proposals by the Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu to end the religious exemption of Haredi youth from serving in Israel’s colonial armed forces.

Haredim and the Zionist Colonial State

Haredi Jewish youth in Jerusalem, reading a Pashkvil
Even before the forcible imposition (‘founding’) of the state of Israel, the Haredim were opposed to Zionism. 

Today the vast majority of Haredim in Israel remain staunchly opposed to the Zionist state for religious, ethical and political reasons.

Haredi religious teaching claims that the Jewish people are bound by three oaths: (1) not to settle in Israel by using force or violence, (2) not to make war with other nations and (3) not to act as if the other nations of the world would persecute Israel.  Haredim opposed Israel’s violent ethnic cleaning of over 850,000 Palestinians in the course of establishing the Israeli State and continues to oppose Israeli settlers’ violently land grabs against Palestinians. 

Unlike other so-called ‘ultra-Orthodox’ sects, who support Zionist colonialism and bless the Israeli military, the Haredim maintain that militarism corrupts the spirit and that Zionists have transformed Jews from righteous followers of the Torah into rabid ethnocentric supporters of a militarist state. 

For the Haredim, ‘state worship’, especially the waving of the Israeli flag in the temple, is a sacrilege comparable to the renegade Jews condemned by Moses for worshipping the Golden Calf.

The majority of Haredim boycott elections, organize their own schools (Yeshivas), encourage students to deepen their religious studies, emphasize community and family values (of a profoundly patriarchal sort) with numerous children and strongly reject the Zionist state’s efforts to conscript Haredi youth into their colonial occupation army, the so-called Israeli Defense (sic) Force (IDF).  All major Zionist political parties and the ruling colonial regime unite to demonize the Haredim, claiming they are shirking their patriotic military responsibilities. Via the mass media and public pronouncements Zionist politicians and the state incite Israeli hatred against the Haredim:  A study in 2006 claimed that over a third of Israeli Jews identified the Haredim as the most unpopular group in Israel.

The Haredim, on the other hand, have reason to fear and loath the secular militarist Zionist state and politicians:  They claim that after World War II in the Zionist-controlled relocation camps for refugee Jewish children in Teheran, the Jewish Agency imposed Zionist ideology and militarist anti-religious policies in order to cut Haredim children off from their spiritual roots.  According to one Haredim report many religious Jewish youth from Poland, mostly survivors of the Holocaust and Soviet Russia, were subjected to “unimaginable mental and physical cruelty with one goal in mind: (the) obliteration of Judaism”.  Given the Israeli drive today to harness a corrupted form of Judaism to serve colonial militarism, the Haredim have every reason to believe that the conscription of their sons and daughters will be accompanied by cruel, systematic Zionist brainwashing to ensure they make efficient (brutal) occupation soldiers.

Haredim versus Israeli State Values

Hasidic boys in Polland in 1910.

The Haredim fervently believe in and practice the Biblical teaching: “Be fruitful and multiply”. They have large families and the median age among the Haredim is 16 years.  Their peaceful message to the militarist Zionists could be summed up as: “Make babies, not bombs”.

Some Haredim leaders have met with Palestinian and Iranian officials and, in line with their religious doctrine, have declared their support for peaceful resolution of conflicts and denounced Israel’s aggressive military posture.

Haredi family in the Satmar community. Photo taken in the Williamsburg neighborhood in Brooklyn, New York

Haredim are intensely religious and dedicate their time to discuss and debate the readings of their great religious scholars:  Their message to the Zionists is to read Maimonides’ ethical treatises rather than listen to Netanyahu’s bellicose, blood curdling rants.

Haredim live and study largely within the confines of their close communities.  They insist on sending their sons to the yeshivas to study religious doctrine rather than to the West Bank to kill Palestinians. They call on their children to serve G-d – not the IDF.  They seek truth in the Torah – not in conquest via the Preventive War Doctrines espoused by prestigious Israeli and overseas Zionist academic militarists.

Haredim focus on building a better life within their community; they reject the efforts of the Zionist state to entice them into joining the violent self-styled ‘Jewish’ settlers engaged in brutal land grabs in the West Bank, in the name of “contributing to society (sic)”.  The ‘introverted Haredi way of life’ is seen as a righteous alternative to the crass militarism, money laundering, financial speculation, human body part trafficking and real estate swindles rife among the elite Israelis and among sectors of overseas Zionists engaged in procuring multi- billion dollar tribute from the US Treasury.

Haredim believe, with exemplary evidence, that conscripting their youth into the Israeli colonial army would destroy their moral values, as their sons would be forced to grope and search Arab women at checkpoints, break the legs of stone-throwing Palestinian children, defend lawless self-styled ‘Jewish’  settlers as they paint obscene graffiti in mosques and churches and attack Arab children on their way to school … not to speak of the ill effects of what secular Israeli Jews call a “modern education”, full of historical fabrications about the origins of Israel, scientific readings on high tech war-making and “advanced” economic doctrines proclaiming the sacred role of the free market, and  justifying the 60% poverty rate among Haredim as “self-induced”.

The Haredim demand that the Israeli Jewish elite stop trying to conscript their youth into the IDF and stop the job discrimination, which has trippled the unemployment rate among Haredim.

The Coming ‘Civil War’:  Zionist State versus the Haredim

The elected leader, Yair Lapid, of newly formed Yesh Atid Party, dubbed a “centrist” by the New York Times,  and a ‘moderate’ by the leading ideologues of the US Zionist “lobby”, ran on a platform of forcibly ending the Haredi exemption from conscription into the colonial military service.  

VOA : A Voice for Change or Same ? Yair Lapid, leader of Yesh Atid party gives a statement outside his home in Tel Aviv, Wednesday, Jan. 23, 2013. (AP Photo/Ariel Schalit)

Yair Lapid, in the run-up to joining a new Netanyahu coalition regime, has launched a vicious attack on the Haredim. Lapid premises his agreement to joining Netanyahu’s war machine on his plans to forcibly confront the Haredi leadership.  Yair Lapid taps the class and secular resentments of Israel’s upwardly mobile youth who bitterly complain of having to serve in the army, thus delaying their money-making opportunities, while the poor, semi-literate “blacks” (a derogatory term referring to the clothing of Haredim) engage in “worthless studies” of the Torah. 

Lapid, using the same perverted logic as Netanyahu, claims that “Ten percent of the population cannot threaten 90 percent with civil war”, (Financial Times, 2/14/13, p. 6.).  Once again, the executioner (Lapid) accuses the victim (Haredim) of the violence he is about to commit. 

Naftali Bennett, new leader of Israel’s Jewish religious right.

Lapid’s Yesh Atid, the centrist (sic) party, has allied with Naftali Bennett’s neo-fascist ‘Jewish Home Party’ (pushing for the annexation of all of Palestine and expulsion of non-Jews) in smashing Haredi exemption to military conscription.  They hold veto power over the next cabinet.  This rabidly secular militarist assault has provoked great opposition and united the otherwise Zionist-religious parties:  The Shas Party (Sephardic Haredim) and United Torah Judaism have taken up the defense of the Haredim.

Lines are being drawn far beyond a Haredim-Zionist State confrontation.

The Larger Meaning of the Haredim-Zionist Conflict

The Haredim hostility to the secular Zionist state is in part based on its opposition to military conscription, thus calling into question Israeli militarism, in general, and specifically its policy of colonial occupation and regional aggression.  While some Haredim may oppose conscription for religious reasons and seek exemption solely for its own youth, objectively, the effect is to undermine Israel’s violation of Palestinian rights and to call into question the entire apartheid system.  By speaking to spiritual values, they deny the legitimacy of the idea of a Jewish police state based on force, violence, torture and disappearance of political prisoners. Their questioning of the institutional configuration upholding Jewish supremacy and Israel as the homeland of the Chosen People, they strike a powerful blow at the ideological underpinnings of the overseas activity of the Zionist power configuration.  Their animosity to the fusion of Jewish chauvinism and religious rituals and the tribal deification of the Israeli state is counterposed to their embrace of Moses Ten Commandments.

The Haredim study the teaching of the profound Judaic philosopher Maimonides and abhor Zionist militaristic strategists like Walzer, Dershowitz, Kagan, Feith, Netanyahu, etc. who preach colonial “just war” doctrines.  Representing 10% of the Israeli population and a far greater percentage of military age youth, the Haredim are in a position to sharply limit the scope of future Zionist wars. If they succeed in blocking conscription, they would provide a lasting contribution to making the world in general, and the Middle East in particular, a more secure and peaceful place to live.

IDF drafted 1,288 Haredi soldiers in 2011, which cost the state about NIS 90 million. Ultra-Orthodox soldiers in a class within the framework of Shahar, Nov. 11, 2010. Photo by Ofer Vaknin

Facing the prospect of a loss of future cannon fodder to sustain its colonial ventures, and in their frenzied attacks on the Haredim, the Israeli-Zionist elite have incited the majority of Israeli Jews to demonize them as ‘backward’, illiterate, freeloaders and to blame the religious curriculum for their growing and current 60% rate of poverty and high unemployment.  Israel’s war machine needs fresh recruits to maintain its imperial quest for a Greater Israel.  Demographics – with families exceeding five children –indicate the Haredim are likely to double their percentage of the Israeli population over the next two decades. Faced with the ‘facts on the ground and in the cradle’, the colonial expansionist imperative drives all the leading Zionist parties to end Haredi exemptions.  In response Haredi leaders threaten to engage in massive civil disobedience if the Zionists impose conscription, rightly seeing conscription of its youth as an assault on its most profoundly held spiritual and family values and as an opening wedge in destroying traditional community solidarity and reciprocal relations.

The Haredim share a common plight with Israel’s Arab population:  Both communities face increasing police harassment, discrimination, religious persecution and rising levels of poverty.  A Haredim-Arab alliance would unite 30% of the population against a common secular militarist and plutocratic enemy.  Farfetched as it seems on the subjective level, there are objective historical and structural processes which are driving the two groups together.

It is one of the great ironies of history that the world’s modern secular anti-imperialist movements should find their most consequential allies among Israel’s most traditional and deeply religious movement.

Dr. James Petras is a Bartle Professor (Emeritus) of Sociology at Binghamton University, New York. He is the author of 65 books published in 29 languages.  His latest book is War Crimes in Gaza and the Zionist Fifth Column in America (Atlanta:Clarity Pres 2010) 

Previous articlePhilip Giraldi : Towards a Christian Zionist Foreign Policy
Next articleJustin Raimondo : Ben Zygier, RIP
James Petras is a Bartle Professor (Emeritus) of Sociology at Binghamton University, New York. He is the author of 64 books published in 29 languages, and over 560 articles in professional journals, including the American Sociological Review, British Journal of Sociology, Social Research, Journal of Contemporary Asia, and Journal of Peasant Studies. He has published over 2000 articles.


  1. Thsi certainly shows the mockery of pretending Jewish values are those driving the Zionist State, when religious Jews are vilified by the militaristic, grasping, cruel leaders and followers of the present government.

  2. It would seem quite clear to a secular observer  that the current  Israel government is quite happy to "pick and choose" those aspects of religious belief that suit their purposes, such  purposes which obviously are contrary to the teachings of so much of the real Jewish religion.    


    These then are the dictates of the politic over the historic and religious.   Able to be tailored to suit.   This does fit in with the accepted character of the Jewish person as known by most observers over forty years and by studying the early days of post WWII Germany. One can almost  table the changes in values, priorities, policies and evil actions to finally reach the stage that we see in this current year. Where those values have spread throughout the world in all the Jewish enclaves and have made the people associated with Israel, that is Israelis, Jews (as a religious following) and those that follow their trail of graft, corruption and influence through largesse, such as the current US Senate and US Congress, are all  outstanding results of this fact.  


    Many years ago, three decades to be precise, my circle involved  many Jewish friends,  four in fact. Lovely people, artistic, well schooled and with a great sense of humour. They were what  I would now call religious Jews, the Synagogue once a week, if convenient,  and the rest of the time fitting in  to the lifestyle they had chosen to be part of, that is, they were Australian citizens. No dual passports then, no trips to Israel, assimilated 100% and enjoying life and respected, in every way.  


    The change was gradual, mentored (influenced) by dictates from their religious associates, withdrawing into themselves and to those of like mind. But the worst aspect of the change was the personality changes from lovers of life to serious and introverted, bordering on antisocial, their new circle almost entirely Jewish and NOW fiercely radical.  


    I do not see them as Australian any more but will remember them as they were, affectionately.   I loved them as friends, as people, as Jewish Australians.   So one does not have to have been to Israel and been subject to the brainwashing at the shrines to the holocaust, the sideshows from the past, to know that there were good Jews who have been forced into another persona either through a sense of misplaced patriotic fervour, not for their Australia as in this case, but for Israel, or as a result of the browbeating and threats from their peers or family.  Commonplace.  


    It is a well-honed skill in Mossad.   Such a person could have been Ben Zygier…educated here but then following a trip to Israel seen as an ideal candidate for ‘turning’. And he was. Who knows whether he remained an Australian throughout it all or not. Suffice to say that he would have represented  hundreds targeted for such roles here in this country and every country.   Actively working for Israel against Australia? Probably, yes. A true sayanim in every way   He made a choice. Ten years he spent in Israel with so many arranged identities, an Israeii speciality as we all know.


    The Dubai assassination comes to mind and how many others, one wonders.  


    Too seldom do we see works from James Petras, all worthy of digestion and the content today reminded me of those past years, my old group of friend’s acceptance of a new life in another country, their values then, their different values now,  little to do with religion in any way at all, but all past values now discarded,……totally And the distorted values now.


    As it is with the examples above, selectively using whatever one wants or chooses to use, discarding that which  one sees as an impediment, disregarding  how important it once was. So it has become with the manipulators of Israel’s mindset.   The convenient changes by Israel in their state’s thinking over forty years, the Israeli propaganda machine’s ability to promote such changes, the Israeli people’s acceptance of those changes, clearly shows how Israel is a frightening adversary against world peace.   Not on their agenda at all.