Excuse Me, But Israel Has No Right To Exist

Excuse Me, But Israel Has No Right To Exist


The most important thing we can do as we hover on the horizon of One State is to shed the old language rapidly. None of it was real anyway – it was just the parlance of that particular “game.” Grow a new vocabulary of possibilities – the new state will be the dawn of humanity’s great reconciliation. Muslims, Christians and Jews living together in Palestine as they once did.


by Sharmine Narwani


The phrase “right to exist” entered my consciousness in the 1990s just as the concept of the two-state solution became part of our collective lexicon. In any debate at university, when a Zionist was out of arguments, those three magic words were invoked to shut down the conversation with an outraged, “are you saying Israel doesn’t have the right to exist??”

Of course you couldn’t challenge Israel’s right to exist – that was like saying you were negating a fundamental Jewish right to have…rights, with all manner of Holocaust guilt thrown in for effect.

Except of course the Holocaust is not my fault – or that of Palestinians. The cold-blooded program of ethnically cleansing Europe of its Jewish population has been so callously and opportunistically utilized to justify the ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian Arab nation, that it leaves me utterly unmoved. I have even caught myself – shock – rolling my eyes when I hear Holocaust and Israel in the same sentence.

What moves me instead in this post-two-state era, is the sheer audacity of Israel even existing.

What a fantastical idea, this notion that a bunch of rank outsiders from another continent could appropriate an existing, populated nation for themselves – and convince the “global community” that it was the moral thing to do. I’d laugh at the chutzpah if this wasn’t so serious.

Even more brazen is the mass ethnic cleansing of the indigenous Palestinian population by persecuted Jews, newly arrived from their own experience of being ethnically cleansed.

But what is truly frightening is the psychological manipulation of the masses into believing that Palestinians are somehow dangerous – “terrorists” intent on “driving Jews into the sea.” As someone who makes a living through words, I find the use of language in creating perceptions to be intriguing. This practice – often termed “public diplomacy” has become an essential tool in the world of geopolitics. Words, after all, are the building blocks of our psychology.

Take, for example, the way we have come to view the Palestinian-Israeli “dispute” and any resolution of this enduring conflict. And here I borrow liberally from a previous article of mine…

The United States and Israel have created the global discourse on this issue, setting stringent parameters that grow increasingly narrow regarding the content and direction of this debate. Anything discussed outside the set parameters has, until recently, widely been viewed as unrealistic, unproductive and even subversive.

Participation in the debate is limited only to those who prescribe to its main tenets: the acceptance of Israel, its regional hegemony and its qualitative military edge; acceptance of the shaky logic upon which the Jewish state’s claim to Palestine is based; and acceptance of the inclusion and exclusion of certain regional parties, movements and governments in any solution to the conflict.

Words like dove, hawk, militant, extremist, moderates, terrorists, Islamo-fascists, rejectionists, existential threat, holocaust-denier, mad mullah determine the participation of solution partners — and are capable of instantly excluding others.

Then there is the language that preserves “Israel’s Right To Exist” unquestioningly: anything that invokes the Holocaust, anti-Semitism and the myths about historic Jewish rights to the land bequeathed to them by the Almighty – as though God was in the real-estate business. This language seeks not only to ensure that a Jewish connection to Palestine remains unquestioned, but importantly, seeks to punish and marginalize those who tackle the legitimacy of this modern colonial-settler experiment.

But this group-think has led us nowhere. It has obfuscated, distracted, deflected, ducked, and diminished, and we are no closer to a satisfactory conclusion…because the premise is wrong.

There is no fixing this problem. This is the kind of crisis in which you cut your losses, realize the error of your ways and reverse course. Israel is the problem. It is the last modern-day colonial-settler experiment, conducted at a time when these projects were being unraveled globally.

There is no “Palestinian-Israeli conflict” – that suggests some sort of equality in power, suffering, and negotiable tangibles, and there is no symmetry whatsoever in this equation. Israel is the Occupier and Oppressor; Palestinians are the Occupied and Oppressed. What is there to negotiate? Israel holds all the chips. They can give back some land, property, rights, but even that is an absurdity – what about everything else? What about ALL the land, property and rights? Why do they get to keep anything – how is the appropriation of land and property prior to 1948 fundamentally different from the appropriation of land and property on this arbitrary 1967 date?

Why are the colonial-settlers prior to 1948 any different from those who colonized and settled after 1967?

Let me correct myself. Palestinians do hold one chip that Israel salivates over – the one big demand at the negotiating table that seems to hold up everything else. Israel craves recognition of its “right to exist.”

But you do exist – don’t you, Israel?

Israel fears “delegitimization” more than anything else. Behind the velvet curtain lies a state built on myths and narratives, protected only by a military behemoth, billions of dollars in US assistance and a lone UN Security Council veto. Nothing else stands between the state and its dismantlement. Without these three things, Israelis would not live in an entity that has come to be known as the “least safe place for Jews in the world.”

Strip away the spin and the gloss, and you quickly realize that Israel doesn’t even have the basics of a normal state. After 64 years, it doesn’t have borders. After six decades, it has never been more isolated. Over half a century later, and it needs a gargantuan military just to stop Palestinians from walking home.

Israel is a failed experiment. It is on life-support – pull those three plugs and it is a cadaver, living only in the minds of some seriously deluded foreigners who thought they could pull off the heist of the century.

The most important thing we can do as we hover on the horizon of One State is to shed the old language rapidly. None of it was real anyway – it was just the parlance of that particular “game.” Grow a new vocabulary of possibilities – the new state will be the dawn of humanity’s great reconciliation. Muslims, Christians and Jews living together in Palestine as they once did.

Naysayers can take a hike. Our patience is wearing thinner than the walls of the hovels that Palestinian refugees have called “home” for three generations in their purgatory camps.

These universally exploited refugees are entitled to the nice apartments – the ones that have pools downstairs and a grove of palm trees outside the lobby. Because the kind of compensation owed for this failed western experiment will never be enough.

And no, nobody hates Jews. That is the fallback argument screeched in our ears – the one “firewall” remaining to protect this Israeli Frankenstein. I don’t even care enough to insert the caveats that are supposed to prove I don’t hate Jews. It is not a provable point, and frankly, it is a straw man of an argument. If Jews who didn’t live through the Holocaust still feel the pain of it, then take that up with the Germans. Demand a sizeable plot of land in Germany – and good luck to you.

For anti-Semites salivating over an article that slams Israel, ply your trade elsewhere – you are part of the reason this problem exists.

Israelis who don’t want to share Palestine as equal citizens with the indigenous Palestinian population – the ones who don’t want to relinquish that which they demanded Palestinians relinquish 64 years ago – can take their second passports and go back home. Those remaining had better find a positive attitude – Palestinians have shown themselves to be a forgiving lot. The amount of carnage they have experienced at the hands of their oppressors – without proportional response – shows remarkable restraint and faith.

This is less the death of a Jewish state than it is the demise of the last remnants of modern-day colonialism. It is a rite of passage – we will get through it just fine. At this particular precipice in the 21st century, we are all, universally, Palestinian – undoing this wrong is a test of our collective humanity, and nobody has the right to sit this one out.

Israel has no right to exist. Break that mental barrier and just say it: “Israel has no right to exist.” Roll it around your tongue, tweet it, post it as your Facebook status update – do it before you think twice. Delegitimization is here – have no fear. Palestine will be less painful than Israel ever was.

Original source: Al-Akhbar English

You can follow Sharmine on twitter @snarwani.

 Related Articles:

Previous articleGiraldi : The Israel Lobby Never Sleeps
Next articleThe Incompatibility of Nakba and Neutrality
Sharmine Narwani is a writer and political analyst covering the Middle East. She has a Master of International Affairs degree from Columbia University’s School of International and Public Affairs in both journalism and Mideast studies. She is a columnist at Alakhbar English. You can follow her on twitter @snarwani.and Room for Debate.


  1. There is a phrase "You have to be Jewish" which tongue in cheek – implies that unless you are a Jew – you can never understand  what makes Jews tick. Whereas Jews have provided a basket full of fun comedians, words that have been included in anyone's vocab (chutzpah for example) – a basket of "This is why we yearn for our homeland – Israel" is a basket tossed aside with contempt by those who see that displaced Jews post Holocaust should have sat outside the camps in Germany, and waited for Europe to rebuild a new home for them. Are you really serious when you suggest this? Do you know what it was like to be a scarecrow on a ship, rejected by every country in the world, following the slaughter of millions?  No… you see Israel as being a new country for refugees. Israel has been Jewish and Arab land for thousands of years. The UN created the new State of Isael in 1948 and since then – her Arab population that stayed have done well. Those who fled – have become refugees in their own lands. For shame!!!! Ask Egypt and ask Jordan why they have  not been given status as Egyptians and Jordanians. Go to Lebanon and ask why their Palestinian refugees are treated like cr*p and  live such a terrible life. Ask why  the Arabs have rejected 9 peace plans – one that offered 98% of the demands asked for? And leave Israel alone. 

    • Gill,

      The presumption that there is room in Palestine for Israel is strictly a sick Zionist fallacy.  They are not even Semitic Jews and they have no rights there at all,  For those who do, or might, if Palestine is the home where their ancestors lived, and they might have a right to go back and live there, then they ought to be content with the Nation which Palestine was then, and was now until the Israelis came and screwed it up,  and not  try to remake it and take over control like they did and have tried to elsewhere in history, the rest of the world, and in present-day Palestine.


      If the European Jew feels he is owed a country because of  his European experience and mistreatment at the hands of the Nazi Germany and the rest of Europe,  let them petition the UN to give them their share of Germany, parts of France and Italy in reparations for the damage to the so called six million Jews and you will see an overnight recount of just how many Jews were stuffed into gas chambers.  Yeah!  Yeah, and you will find out exactly how "guilty" most Germans, French and Italians feel about what they did… or didn't do. 


      And, you might get some real "Holocaust" revisionism!


      Try scratching a Jew in America you are not going to find an Irishman, a Chinaman, or a Uighur.  More often than not, you will simply find one more Jew.  Push him far enough, and he will run out the blue and white banners, shake his little fist, and shout anti-Semitic at you, and almost unlimited number of special interest, ALL of them Jewish interests, and no interests in anything not related somehow to Jewishness, being Jewish, Zionism, or what is "good for the Jew."  that is not only the bottom line, it is the ONLY line!  


      They may seem to be supporting many causes and serving many masters, but there is but ONE prime cause and only ONE prime Master!  Themselves!  They have no allies, for they have  no equals.  Everyone else, all else is subservient to their welfare.


      In that context, the entire US/Israeli relationship makes sense and is understandable.


      The declassified intelligence on Israeli espionage against America has been out a long time and it is devastating (Follow Grant F. Smith's writing and Research, author of The Spy Trade). The classified stuff must be worse ?


      Read Karen Friedman, she has had it rough.  She is Jewish!  All Jews have it rough.  Their ontological mythology teaches them that they are born victims!  That is the "chosen"  thing for which they were "chosen." 


      Read the words of Menachem Begin, that great Founder of Israel and instrument of god's Jewish destiny!


      Earlier I could not bring myself to condemn all Jews for what probably minorities in Israel are doing… but in these past few decades it becomes difficult when, we observe. eighty percent of the others stand on the sidelines cheering them on.  It seems when they stand and cheer that they are being more than just "good Germans." 


      If opposing Jewish militarism, racism and oppression makes me an anti-semite, or a bigot, then that is a badge of honor I will wear with pride….

      I have been pissing-off jews on a daily basis for years…and have been a recipient of the highest honor, that is all I can do  and, frankly, I am having a good time doing it as you can see here.

      No love lost. They should be as pissed-off as I am about what is being done in their name to create a jewish state. 

      After 6 decades of occupying anothers land, 80 percent of Israelis supported the last assault on Gaza, that is the straw that broke the camel's back for me. 

      How does one make a distinction?  Not until we see jews all over the world come out in defense of the innocent defenseless children being killed, hundreds of  thousads maimed and turned into orphans and refugees over night becoz of senseless wars being fought for Israel's security.


      I think you should think about these things a bit longer before you run your  mouth here in the comments section and start blabbing as if  you think you know what you are talking about. 


      I am tired of repeating myself,  persuading the likes of you  is akin to reading Shakespeare to the illiterate.




    I initiated a series on Anti-Semitism, what is it, a while back, I provide a link below to the series, which is required reading for those who continue to be intimidated by bigotry and anti-semite labels, It is obviously NOT anti-Semitism, even though they have always called it that and, for decades it has successfully stilled a lot of legitimate criticism of Israel’s policies.


    Alan Hart, Jeff Gates, Alan Sabrosky, Maidhc Ó Cathail, Paul Balles, Prof. Cook, contributed to the series…each piece a masterpiece, enjoy :

    Are the defenders of fake ‘Antisemitism’ losing their edge ?


  3. I'm always amazed by the hoops some Arabs/ Muslims jump through, the moral and logical straight lines they bend and twist and overwork till they are no longer recognizable; just to attempt to demonstrate that Arabs/Muslims are entitled to self determination and Jews aren't. It obviously sells well to those who think they are superior to others.  Reasonable people of good will just shake their heads and turn away and tune out.