Guenter Grass, German Nobel Winner, Criticizes Israel Over Iran Tensions

Guenter Grass, German Nobel Winner, Criticizes Israel Over Iran Tensions


"The nuclear power Israel is endangering the already fragile world peace," Grass wrote in his poem titled:

“What Must Be Said”


by Juergen Baetz


German writer Guenter Grass gives a television interview shortly after speaking in support of the German Social Democrats (SPD) in Berlin, Germany. (Photo by Sean Gallup/Getty Images)

HUFPO — German Nobel literature laureate Guenter Grass labeled Israel a threat to "already fragile world peace" in a poem published Wednesday that drew sharp rebukes at home and from Israel.

In the poem titled "What must be said," published in German daily Sueddeutsche Zeitung and Italy's La Repubblica among others, Grass criticized what he described as Western hypocrisy over Israel's own suspected nuclear program amid speculation that it might engage in military action against Iran to stop it building a suspected atomic bomb.

The 84-year-old Grass said he had been prompted to put pen to paper by Berlin's recent decision to sell Israel a submarine able to "send all-destroying warheads where the existence of a single nuclear bomb is unproven."

"The nuclear power Israel is endangering the already fragile world peace," he wrote. His poem specifically criticized Israel's "claim to the right of a first strike" against Iran.

Grass also called for "unhindered and permanent control of Israel's nuclear capability and Iran's atomic facilities through an international body."

Israel views Iran as a threat to its existence, citing among other things some Iranian calls for its destruction and fears that Iran aims to produce nuclear weapons.

Grass didn't mention those calls, which have been made by President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, but obliquely referred to the Iranian people being "subjugated by a loudmouth."

Israel is widely believed to have an arsenal of nuclear weapons but has never admitted it, pursuing instead an official policy of "ambiguity" to deter potential attackers.

DOLPHIN SUBMARINE -- Now the two countries have agreed that Israel may buy the sixth submarine, with Germany helping to finance a third of the whopping $528-million price tag that makes the vessel one of the world's most expensive war machines. LA TIMES

Israel currently has three Dolphin submarines from Germany – one half-funded and two entirely funded by Berlin – two more are currently under construction, and the contract for a sixth submarine was signed last month.

Dolphin-class submarines can carry nuclear-tipped missiles, but there's no evidence Israel has armed them with such weapons.

The West sees Iran's nuclear program as designed to develop an atomic bomb, but Tehran denies the charge, saying an expansion of its enrichment program is meant only to provide nuclear fuel.

Grass said he long kept silent on Israel's own nuclear program because his country committed "crimes that are without comparison," but he has come to see that silence as a "burdensome lie and a coercion" whose disregard carries a punishment – "the verdict 'anti-Semitism' is commonly used."

The left-leaning Grass established himself as a leading literary figure with "The Tin Drum," published in 1959, and won the Nobel Prize in 1999. He urged fellow Germans to confront their painful Nazi history in the decades after World War II.

However, his image suffered a bruising when he admitted in his 2006 autobiography that he was drafted into the Waffen-SS, the combat arm of the Nazis' paramilitary organization, in the final months of World War II.

Grass' comments swiftly drew sharp criticism Wednesday.

"What must also be said is that Israel is the world's only nation whose right to exist is publicly questioned," the Israeli Embassy in Germany said in a statement. "We want to live in peace with our neighbors in the region."

"Guenter Grass is turning the situation upside-down by defending a brutal regime that not only disregards but openly violates international agreements for many years," said Deidre Berger, director of the American Jewish Committee in Berlin.

"Iran is the threat for world peace – and Israel the only democracy in the entire region, and at the same time the world's only whose right to exist is openly questioned," said Charlotte Knobloch, a former leader of Germany's Jewish community.

Efraim Zuroff, who leads the Nazi-hunting Simon Wiesenthal Center in Jerusalem, called Grass' poem "outrageous," adding it appeared to be a sign of Israel "becoming the whipping boy for the frustrations of those who are sick of hearing about the Holocaust."

German Chancellor Angela Merkel is a staunch ally of Israel, and her spokesman reacted coolly to Grass' remarks.

"There is artistic freedom in Germany, and there thankfully also is the freedom of the government not to have to comment on every artistic production," Steffen Seibert said.

The head of the German Parliament's foreign affairs committee – lawmaker Ruprecht Polenz, a member of Merkel's Christian Democrats – told the daily Mitteldeutsche Zeitung that Grass is a great author "but he always has difficulties when he speak about politics and mostly gets it wrong."

"The country that worries us is Iran," he was quoted as saying, adding that "his poem distracts attention from that."

Grass' assistant Hilke Ohsoling told German news agency dapd Wednesday that the author won't explain or defend his poem, nor does he plan to comment on the reactions in the near future because of health issues.

SOURCE:  Huffington Post


Juergen Baetz can be reached on Twitter at


  1. No surprise, German Government has disavowed Günter's position and the US Government we assume has picked up the other half of the tab for the Dolphin Submarines. Numbskulls!

  2. The only one who questions Israel's right to exist is…Israel. I hear no rhetoric from any other nation on the planet about this, yet Israel keeps using it as a war cry in order to expand it's borders. Its leaders are a bunch of paranoid schizophrenics.
    While I admire Grass' words, he apparently did not get the memo that Ahmedinejad never said that Israel should be wiped out. Rather that is a poor interpretation by MEMRI, a Zionist propaganda tool that "translates" Arab languages into English. The quote actually related to the Zionist regime and equated it to Communist Russia.

  3. Finally! I've waited for so long – this is an answer to prayer, no kidding! At 84 yrs o, someone speaks up about such a crucial matter he has observed.
    And you know somebody, he probably  had seen a lot more but it was just about time to say something. I wept and wept, as I weep and weep often for these precious people.  Oh, may many more speak up, they don't have to be disrespectful to anyone, just speak out the truth while minding the dignity of others and theirs.  I pray God this is a new dawn for this country reagding the ME issues. Truth, neither you nor Germans will remain casualties.
    What a day!

  4. The oficial Israeli comments are lies. Iran is no threat,has disobeyed no international laws. Israel 's existence is not an issue, Israel is not democratic and is certainly NOT interested in peace with its neighbours or its native population (those with no right of return if they leave at all). Grass has not said anything false. Nukes are a danger anywhere, and all the neighbours of Israel including Iran, want them removed.

  5. In the 14th century Germany sold brass canons that the Turks used to knock down the walls of Constantanoble, leading to 400 years of Turkish occupation of the Balkens.  The fighting and killing thats gone on in the last few years there is a direct result of those German  weapon sales.
    Fast forward and we now see Germany "selling" submarines to the state of Israel which Israel will use to start WW111.
    How can a country (Germany) that makes such good cars be so stupid?