It’s time to open the windows and introduce a breath of fresh air. Lyndon B. Johnson is gone and so is his Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara, both of whom left the USS Liberty to its fate. But there are many survivors who are still looking for answers. It is time to provide what they need and give them peace.

by Phil Giraldi

Foreword by Alison Weir / Council for the National Interest

Forty-four years ago seems like a long time and, in terms of fashion or family photo albums, it is.

But the June 8, 1967 Israeli attack on the USS Liberty is still an important issue. Thirty-four American sailors and civilian personnel were killed … over 170 more were wounded.

An independent, blue-ribbon commission including a former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff and a Marine General who was the highest ranking recipient of the Congressional Medal of Honor conducted an investigation in 2003. Their report contained explosive findings, including: The truth about Israel’s attack and subsequent White House cover-up continues to be concealed from the American people to the present day and is a national disgrace.

Now, Phil Giraldi, CNI’s Executive Director, has uncovered new and startling information. In an article just published, Phil reports …

“A crewman on the USS Amberjack, [an] intelligence gathering sub, has provided an account of his ship’s activities on that day in June [and] the ship’s log confirms that it was indeed in the area. The sub’s crew knew that a US Navy vessel was under attack, but the Amberjack was only lightly armed and in no position to intervene. The [Amberjack] crewmen feared that they themselves might be hit by the torpedoes that the Israeli warships were firing.”

The article continues “Several Liberty crewmen reported seeing a periscope during the attack and it has generally been assumed that it was Israeli.”

Now we know differently.

Phil reveals this:

“The photos and videos of the incident made by Amberjack were subsequently couriered to Washington by a ship’s officer, where they were turned over to the Pentagon.”

Where is this evidence today? Was it destroyed? Is it collecting dust on a shelf ?

This new information must be circulated in the halls of Congress and in the media. CNI (The Council for the National Interest ) will do its part in demanding hearings and investigations. I’m asking you to do the same …

1. Send the link to Phil Giraldi’s article to your member of Congress
2. Send it to family, friends, and activists who should be aware of a cover up
3. Send letters, with a link to the article, to the media.
4. Support CNI’s efforts to spread the word on this scoop.

It’s time to come to the aid of the surviving crew members of the USS Liberty by publicizing Phil Giraldi’s exclusive findings. Will you help?

We must act now while the new revelations are fresh.

Former U.S. Senator and current CNI Board member James Abourezk has observed: “Allowing the lies told by the Israelis and their minions in the U.S. is disheartening to all of us who are proud of our servicemen and women.”

Demanding justice for American soldiers who were betrayed by government operatives?who were working in collusion with powerful special interest groups?is in the best American tradition of patriotic values.


Please join with me in demanding the truth about what really happened to the USS Liberty. Forty-four years is a long time, but not too long for justice to be served.

Wonder how relevant the attack on the USS Liberty is to today’s Middle East news?

Israel is still attacking ships it deems a “threat.”  Last May, Israeli armed forces attacked a flotilla of aid-carrying ships aiming to break the country’s siege on Gaza. Nine people were killed, including a 19-year-old with American citizenship shot execution style in the head. The attack took place in international waters.

Please be generous in this fight. Contributions of $500 are vital, and gifts of $50 are also necessary to get the job done. CNI needs all hands on deck. Your gift of $35, $50 $100 or more will help CNI deliver this message.

Sinking Liberty

Who will write the final chapter on Israel’s 1967 confrontation with the U.S. Navy?

By Philip Giraldi

The attack on the USS Liberty by Israeli warplanes and torpedo boats on June 8, 1967 has almost faded from memory, but new evidence suggests that the White House might actually have had prior knowledge that the ship would be struck by Israel’s armed forces. In the worst attack ever carried out on a U.S. Naval vessel in peacetime, 34 American sailors and civilian personnel were killed and 171 more wounded in the two hour assault, which was clearly intended to sink the intelligence-gathering vessel operating in international waters collecting information on the ongoing Six-Day War between Israel and its Arab neighbors.

The Israelis and their supporters in the United States have always claimed the attack was a tragic mistake while many of the surviving Liberty crew believe that it was anything but: They assert that the vessel was flying an oversized American flag and was clearly identifiable as a U.S. Navy vessel. The ship’s commanding officer, Captain William McGonagle, was awarded a Congressional Medal of Honor for his role in keeping the ship afloat, though President Lyndon Baines Johnson broke with tradition by refusing to hold the medal ceremony in the White House, or to award it personally, delegating that task to the Secretary of the Navy in an unpublicized presentation at the Washington Navy Yard.

The Liberty crew was sworn to secrecy over the incident and a hastily-convened court of inquiry headed by Admiral John McCain acted under orders from Washington to declare the attack a case of mistaken identity. The inquiry’s senior legal counsel Captain Ward Boston, who subsequently declared the attack to be a “deliberate effort to sink an American ship and murder its entire crew,” also described how “President Lyndon Johnson and Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara ordered him to conclude that the attack was a case of ‘mistaken identity’ despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary.” The court’s findings were rewritten and sections relating to possible war crimes, such as the machine-gunning of life rafts, were excised. Following in his father’s footsteps, Senator John McCain of Arizona has used his position on the Senate Armed Services Committee to effectively block any reconvening of a board of inquiry to reexamine the evidence. Most of the documents relating to the Liberty incident have never been released to the public.

One of the more intriguing allegations surrounding the Liberty incident is the claim that a United States Navy submarine was in the area when the attack took place. A number of submarine crewmen have surfaced anonymously to say that they were on one of several subs reported to be in the area on intelligence-gathering missions. Some stated their belief that photos were taken of the attack itself, but, fearing reprisals from the government, none would go public with their claims.

More recently, a crewman on the USS Amberjack, a diesel-powered intelligence-gathering sub, has provided an account of his ship’s activities on that day in June to two Liberty survivors. The sailor, Larry Bryant, agreed to go on radio with survivors Phil Tourney and Ron Kukal to discuss his experiences but inexplicably got cold feet and broke off contact. However, several extended phone conversations had already provided some intriguing insights into what had taken place.

Several Liberty crewmen reported seeing a periscope during the attack and it has generally been assumed that it was Israeli, but according to Bryant, it was actually the USS Amberjack. The submarine was near enough to the incident to clearly hear throughout the ship the reverberations of every round fired into the Liberty’s hull. The sub’s crew knew that a U.S. Navy vessel was under attack, but the Amberjack was only lightly armed and in no position to intervene. The sub remained immobile between the Liberty and some of its attackers and  the sub’s crewmen feared that they themselves might be hit by the the Israeli warships’ torpedos.

As Larry Bryant was a crewman, he had no idea why the submarine was in that spot on that day, but he did note how the sub had raised its periscope and was observing the attack as it unfolded. More interestingly, the submarine had been equipped with a platform for the mounting of a video camera, which operated through the periscope and the Amberjack both filmed and photographed the entire incident. Some crewmen noted that the Liberty’s large American flag was clearly visible through the periscope during the attack, disputing the subsequent Israeli contention that the ship was not flying any flag.

The Amberjack’s Captain August Hubal, now retired and living in Virginia, has denied that his ship was anywhere near the Liberty on June 8th, but his account is contradicted by the ship’s log which confirms that it was indeed in the area. Hubal, who was described by Bryant as an obsessive, “by the rules” officer who would go to his stateroom and blow his brains out if so ordered, later warned his crew to forget about their role in the Liberty attack or face the consequences. The photos and videos of the incident made by the Amberjack were subsequently couriered to Washington by a ship’s officer, where they were turned over to the Pentagon.

Part of Hubal’s reluctance to discuss what he was doing on that day might be traced to the fact that his vessel was carrying out a clandestine operation in Egyptian waters as part of the Naval Security Group, which was affiliated with the codebreakers of the National Security Agency. Several civilians on the sub were performing the same tasks as their counterparts who were intercepting and decoding radio transmissions on board the Liberty. The Amberjack was equipped with a snorkel, which enabled it to sit on the bottom of the sea immobile and listen to electronic transmissions for long periods of time.

Confirmation that the Amberjack was in the area and that it had made a film and photo record of the attack suggest a number of lines for further inquiry. First and foremost has to be the issue of possible prior knowledge or even connivance by the White House in what was about to take place. Was it happenstance that the submarine was in the same location as the Liberty or was it by design? Was there any advance notice to Washington that an attack might take place? Could the USS Liberty have been an intended victim of a false flag simulated Egyptian attack, leading to American involvement on behalf of Israel in the fighting? Though that line of inquiry might appear implausible, the White House ordered the return of US warplanes sent to assist the Liberty, suggesting that Johnson knew who the attackers were in spite of the fact that the Israelis had covered over their aircraft markings in an apparent attempt to blame the Egyptians. One might also recall the Gulf of Tonkin incident.

Was the video equipment part of the ship’s standard espionage gear or was it installed just prior to the Liberty attack? Was the filming of the attack done on an opportunity basis or was it planned? Was it possibly intended to provide evidence of Egyptian aggression, played for all its worth on the nightly news in America? Most importantly, where are the video and other photos today and why were they not produced at the board of inquiry or subsequently?

To those who object that Lyndon Baines Johnson would not have sunk so low as to allow an American warship to be attacked, it should be observed that LBJ’s refusal to allow air cover might mean that the situation was being managed to produce a “correct” outcome. One might also recall that Lyndon Johnson was possibly the most pro-Israel president in American history, tilting heavily towards the Jewish state on foreign policy issues starting with his time as a congressman all the way through his years in the White House. When he was president he declared a “strategic alliance” with Israel.

The Amberjack story, for all those who would like to see the Liberty saga end either in exonerating Israel or in proving its guilt, provides closure. The attack took place 44 years ago. Whatever classified information or sources and methods used by the intelligence community worth protecting then are surely well beyond their shelf life now. It is time to open the files fully. The activity of the Amberjack, including its classified logs and whatever film and photos it might have taken, should be made accessible, together with the testimony of surviving crewmen. And when that material is fully digested, there should be another court of inquiry to look in the matter finally and completely, incorporating the testimony of all the surviving Liberty crewmen, particularly those who were not heard the first time around because they were in hospital or were restrained by orders not to discuss the incident.

WikiLeaks has demonstrated that the United States has a secret government that operates with little in the way or transparency or restraint. Unfortunately, it has had that kind of government for a long time, and the fate of the USS Liberty could be a manifestation of how the White House might actually have colluded in the deaths of American servicemen and then engaged in a cover-up to conceal what it had done. It’s time to open the windows and introduce a breath of fresh air. Lyndon B. Johnson is gone and so is his Secretary of Defense Robert McNamara, both of whom left the USS Liberty to its fate. But there are many survivors who are still looking for answers. It is time to provide what they need and give them peace.


Philip Giraldi, a former CIA Officer, is the Executive Director of the Council for the National Interest. His “Deep Background” column appears every month exclusively in The American Conservative.

Read more:


  1. george beres on the 24. Mar, 2011 remarked #

    We in Eugene, Ore., have held public programs to reveal the government lies that have hidden Israel’s lies about its murder of our sailors on The Liberty. I am developing an expose on this scandal with material from two McNamara assistants of the time: Daniel Ellsberg and the late John McNaughton. I invite others to forward me any relevant material. – George Beres, geosilberes@q.com
    1990 Dogwood Drive
    Eugene, Oregon 97405

  2. Long List on the 24. Mar, 2011 remarked #

    Might want to tag Khobar Towers, the U.S.S. Cole, and the Beirut Marine Barracks bombing to the war crimes, and while you’re at it, add what took place on Sept. 11th., 2001 to the pile of dead at the hands of the mossad/Israel.

    Link L.T. McFadden’s 1932 floor speech, and take a good look at the ‘coincidence’ that in 1913, the Anti-Defamation League was formed to protect Zionist Banksters who just enslaved this nation.

    …then the bigger picture emerges.

    We could only wish it were just the U.S.S. Liberty sailors who have been murdered, but Furkan Dogan’s parents know better.

  3. Rexw on the 24. Mar, 2011 remarked #

    Having followed the perfidious action of the Israelis in this matter and the almost traitorous action of the administration and US President Johnson, a positive disgrace, I have never understood how such a matter could have been allowed to not be properly investigated.

    It seems that the USA will go to any lengths to maintain its subservient position to the most disliked state in the world and for some unimaginable reason seems to have no idea how this makes the world think of them…a weak and spineless country, content to attack women and children in Iraq, Afghanistan and now Libya but has not got the decency to investigate the death of sailors from America, their own country.

    Nothing to me seems such an act of perfidy that has been allowed to be swept under the carpet for 44 years.

    They should hang their heads in shame and every President since that day for not ensuring that the matter was aired.

    Thanks to the likes of Philip Giraldi yet again and the remaining crew of the USS Liberty, we all know the real criminals. Israel, yet again, rubbing your nose in it, year after year.

    Prosecute the bastards and while you are at it, clear the air on 9/11 as well.

    You might win back some respect, but certainly not from me for having shirked your responsibility in the first place. To me, that’s unforgivable.

    Johnson should have his history removed from all the records for this despicable deed as should Bush for Iraq and Kennedy for Laos and Cambodia.

    Where does the US find such people?

  4. john hawk on the 25. Mar, 2011 remarked #

    Traitors? Just go to the White House and pick one, or all, presidential occupants from the last 100 years…!

    …all sociopaths to boot!

  5. kim hanna on the 27. Mar, 2011 remarked #

    I just contacted both my US Senators (again)in Rhode Island about investigating Israel’s attack on our Navy.

    There’s no statute of limitations on murder and America needs to understand that Israel is not an ally of America but is an adversary and dangerous to our nation.

  6. kim hanna on the 28. Mar, 2011 remarked #

    Rexw commented:”You might win back some respect, but certainly not from me for having shirked your responsibility in the first place. To me, that’s unforgivable.”

    When did you risk court marshal and betray your oath of service to the nation;

    as you expect Mr. Giraldi to have done.

    Please tell us and give us a description of how and where you did this.

  7. Rexw on the 28. Mar, 2011 remarked #


    This is not addressed to Philip Giraldi as I have great respect for his writings. Always have had. He is one of the best.

    My argument and comments in this case are addressed to the USA. ” you (the USA) may win back some respect but not from me,….”etc.

    The point I was trying to make in a hurry (and perhaps having an element of confusion for which I apologize, particularly to Philip if this was his understanding as well) was that in my lifetime this registers as the greatest act of perfidy I know of. The fact that it was not acted upon is a continuing disgrace and the beginning of the arrogance of Israel knowing that if they got away with this, they can get away with anything….and they have for 40+ years.

    It pains me to think of what the surviving crew must think about the whole disgraceful matter and their country’s dismissal of the affair.

    Sorry for any confusion.

  8. twb on the 17. Aug, 2011 remarked #

    Why has this not been published, in full page Sunday, ad’s across the country ?

  9. Earlaiman on the 18. Aug, 2011 remarked #

    Neither the US Congress, nor any other US Government agency will call for an investigation of the attack on the USS Liberty, its treasonous abandonment by the Highest US Command Authority and the subsequent white-wash and coverup, until the time and atmosphere are politically and diplomatically “right” for such an investigation.

    It is constant and unrelenting efforts like this, and the publication and widespread dissemination of news and information about these efforts, the attack on USS Liberty, the cover-up, and the efforts of her crew to be heard and seek redress for the crimes perpetrated against them by both Israel and their own Government which will, in time, change the political and diplomatic environment to such an extent that the time will become “right” and such an investigation will be called.

    Have faith,guys… stick in there and keep kicking back at the pricks. The truth will out, and Justice will eventually be served.

    We may none of us be alive when that happens, but justice is immortal, and it will prevail.

    In the meanwhile, keep swimming as strongly as you can, and don’t let them push you under.


Leave a Comment